[kj] Early american KJ articles
nicholas fitzpatrick
gasw30 at hotmail.com
Thu Aug 19 05:00:48 EDT 2004
For anyone who's interested, here's three early American articles about KJ,
running in reverse order from 1982 (review of Revelations), through 1981
(gig review) to a short article moaning about the cost of going out on New
Year's Eve in New York in 1980 (KJ's NY debut). None of it is exactly
flattering...
1982 The Washington Post
Punk Pretenses
By Howard Wuelfing
It shouldn't come as a surprise that Killing Joke draws fans from the heavy
metal coterie or that Duran Duran has made lots of friends in suburban
discos. Both of these British bands are considered New Wave, but in England
nowadays, all that label guarantees is a certain novelty value and a
marketable image. Innumerable groups, including these two, have used punk's
credos of innovation and individuality as a pretense for hopping bandwagons,
going from one trend or style to another in a quest for Old Wave-style
success.
Killing Joke, which performs at the 9:30 club on Saturday, incorporates a
great deal of the vision and sound of '70s hard rock into the "prog-punk"
(progressive punk) format. The group's stance is violent, macho and
anti-sentimental, the same sort of pose that the likes of Black Sabbath
employ.
Almost every number on "Revelations" (Editions E.G./ Malicious Damage, EGMD
3), Killing Joke's most recent LP, is an overwrought, near-impenetrable
mess. The basic elements are definitely derived from punk, but something
about the context, the delivery and the intent has gone horribly wrong.
Time after time the group goes after sensationalistic effects, readily
achieved bits of cheap theater. "Chop Chop" is a rumbling menace, Geordie's
bombastic guitars, a dully throbbing rhythm section and Jaz Coleman's
bellowing vocalese all battering the ears. They saddled "Dregs," already a
weak tune, with a ponderous, leaden tempo and sloppy disco mix -- more
failed atmospherics. Killing Joke attempts repeatedly to imbue this material
with an aura of power and profundity. Instead it sounds overbearing and
pretentious.
The results are overwhelmingly tedious and trite. It's about as politically
enlightening, or even threatening, as watching Japanese sci-fi flicks on a
Saturday afternoon. Never mind that the radiation-induced boogie monsters --
or worse -- are a real possibility. No sincere emotions are exposed, no
substantial points made. Killing Joke nearly plays to its audience's morbid
preconceptions. This probably explains the group's popularity among
adolescent would-be psychopaths. It offers easy answers, a vulgar reduction
of more complex realities.
Duran Duran, which opens for Blondie at Merriweather Post Pavilion Monday,
performs a similar disservice for dance-floor dilettantes. The New Romantic
movement the group emerged from was a wry, knowing adaptation of disco and
glitter conventions in opposition to punk's elitism of ugliness.
>From the word go, Duran Duran was a packaging concept. The moment the group
was signed, its record company hired Roxy Music's haberdasher to dress them,
Magazine's graphic designer to do their record sleeve art work and the
engineer from David Bowie's "Heroes" sessions to produce. In fact,
everything except showing the band how to write, play or sing properly was
done for them.
"Rio" (Harvest, ST-12211) is tepid, anonymous electro-pop slop. The tunes
are flat and nondescript and, even worse, awkward. The title cut stumbles
back and forth between ill-suited chorus and verse sections. "Hungry Like a
Wolf" tries to propel a terribly plain melody with a thumping stodgy beat to
no avail. Throughout, the musicianship is pedestrian and the singing
bland--and very wisely buried in the mix.
Any bright points on "Rio" should be credited to producer Colin Thurston.
He's dressed up drab tracks like "Last Chance on the Stairway" with a legion
of tasteful flourishes, a tinkling splash of vibes in this case. Elsewhere
there are sudden bursts of percussion, subtle tonal variations. "Hold Back
the Rain," the most brazen Roxy pop here, benefits greatly from his sly
manipulation of timbre and texture. Thurston almost renders this stuff
listenable.
ENDS
1981 Washington Post
Killing ----Joke ------
by Harry Sumrall
What with the riots, the depressed economy and the shrinking empire, all is
not right in Britain. The atmosphere seems to have affected the island's
rock groups, many of whom have gone fairly potty from the despair of it all.
Last night at the 9:30 Club, Killing Joke erupted with its own version of
English working-class angst rock. Menacing lyrics that dealt with madness,
tension and food shortages were yelled above a screeching, crashing
electronic wall of sound. No melodies. No harmonies. In fact, Killing Joke
sounded rather like a synthesized equivalent of a chain saw.
The four musicians exuded a kind of manic charm, casting anguished glances
and militant poses at the frenzied crowd. While these were no doubt intended
to heighten the effect of the music, the result was nonetheless hilarious.
And the music -- well, it was in the finest rock-for-shock tradition, with
blaring, amateurish riffing and screaming singers trying to purge some sort
of demons from their souls. It was so bad that it was supposed to be good --
except it never got past being bad.
Killing Joke. The joke is on the group as well as its listeners. And it
isn't very amusing.
ENDS
1980 The New York Times Company
December 27, 1980, Saturday
COST OF A NEW YEAR'S EVE SOARS UP AND AWAY
By ENID NEMY
Stand in line with money, because New Year's Eve may be fun, frolic and good
will, but it is also a bundle of cash - in most cases, anywhere from 10 to
33 percent higher than last year
The Rock Lounge at West Broadway and Canal Street is charging $25 a person
to dance and listen to the New York debut of Killing Joke, a New Wave group
from England....
_________________________________________________________________
Want to block unwanted pop-ups? Download the free MSN Toolbar now!
http://toolbar.msn.co.uk/
More information about the Gathering
mailing list